top of page
Search

Why Medication is NOT Your Solution for Chronic Sleep Issues

Approximately half of all Canadian adults struggle with sleep, with recent data indicating an increasing trend in sleep difficulties and diagnosed insomnia (Public Health Agency of Canada, 2025). These individuals are often looking for a quick fix, and in response, up to 70% have turned to a sleeping aid or have used cannabis-derived products or alcohol in the last year (Morin et al. 2024).


Sleep aids include prescription medications, over-the-counter drugs, and dietary supplements, many of which are labelled as “natural” sleep aids. Within those categories are multiple types of drugs and compounds that affect the body in distinct ways. While every sleep aid has potential benefits, it also has potential risks that need to be considered. 



Potential Risks of Sleep Medication:

The potential downsides of sleep aids vary based on the specific medication and the person taking them. Some risks of taking sleep aids include:


  • Dependence and withdrawal: while sleeping pills are often only prescribed for short-term relief, a person may become dependent on them and experience worsening insomnia or other symptoms when stopping.


  • Decreasing effectiveness: people can build up a tolerance to many medications, reducing their benefits and potentially worsening side effects if the dosage is increased.


  • Excessive grogginess: the sleepiness induced by many sleep aids can affect a person’s thinking and balance. Being too groggy may create a higher risk of falls or other accidents at night, especially for older adults and people with conditions like dementia. 


  • Next-day drowsiness: the effects of some sleeping pills can be long-lasting, continuing to affect a person when they wake up the next day. In a research, as many as 80% of people taking sleep aids reported at least one residual effect like trouble concentrating, experiencing dizziness or confused thoughts the next day. These daytime effects, which is similar to feeling hungover, can negatively impact one's ability to drive, work, go to school and complete daily tasks (Fitzgerald, 2015).


  • Disturbed sleep quality: many common medications significantly disrupt sleep architecture by suppressing REM and slow-wave sleep. These substances can reduce deep sleep (Stages 3-4), lead to shorter, fragmented sleep cycles, and cause REM rebound (intense dreams) upon withdrawal (Feriante & Singh, 2024). 


  • Interactions with other drugs: there can be many interactions between prescription medicines, over-the-counter drugs, and dietary supplements. These interactions can intensify or reduce the potency of drugs and may cause unintended consequences. 


None Curative:

Moreover, although these "quick fixes" for sleep might seem attractive for quickly restoring our sleep so we can continue with our busy lives, it is important to understand that medications or any type of sleep aid do not cure chronic insomnia. Once the medication is stopped, insomnia will almost always come back as they do not address the root cause of insomnia (Hassigner et al. 2020). 


Pranshu Adavadkar, Sleep Medicine Physician reports that “sleep aids, while seemingly harmless and often overused as quick fixes, carry their own set of side effects. Sleep issues often originate from underlying sleep disorders, other medical or mental conditions, or unhealthy sleep habits. Sleep aids, rather than tackling the root of the problem, may simply mask it or, in some cases, even exacerbate the situation.”


How to REALLY Address Insomnia to Prevent Its Recurrence:

A well-established effective intervention to tackle the root of insomnia is cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBT-I), as reported by the World Sleep Society. CBT-I helps uncover and reorient negative thinking about sleep while encouraging better sleep hygiene.

CBT-I is considered the first-line treatment for chronic insomnia. For chronic insomnia, CBT-I is more effective than medications. As many as 70% to 80% of patients with primary insomnia experience improvements. Benefits include less time to fall asleep, more time spent asleep, and waking up less during sleep. Results are often maintained over time. In contrast, patients co-treated with medication may see lessened long-term durability, specifically failing to exhibit the increases in total sleep time typically seen after completing CBT-I alone. Because of its superior long-term profile and safety, organizations such as the American and Canadian College of Physicians, the European Sleep Research Society, and many others recommend CBT-I as the initial treatment for chronic insomnia.



Closing Remarks:

While sleep aids remain an available option for individuals experiencing sleep difficulties, it is important to be well informed. Sleeping pills are often prescribed for short-term relief only from sleep disturbances and the effectiveness can vary and side effects may arise. Consulting with a healthcare profession is recommended to see how to best approach your particular sleep issue.



References:

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page